QUOTE(Liam @ Mar 13 2009, 06:25 AM) [snapback]539554[/snapback]
But does he really lose? I mean (without giving too much away) Rorschach is the only one among them who remains truly good, without compromise. If anything he's the greatest hero of them all.
truly good? nothing about Rorschach could really be described as "good" besides his concept of what is wrong.
the whole point of ozzymadis offing people but still saving the world even though he hated killing, didn't he make a big sacrifice? besides of course the argument he blamed it on john, but thats the only way it would have been believable.
john I think is a metaphor for the fear in god that keeps people from flipping out horribly.
also was real weird how I was waiting to see if they were gonna show john's dick like they did in the book under exaggerated, instead gave him swinging pipe. which I funny to me because when they did that silk spectre II love scene I was like "alright already they fuck lets break out Rorschach".
this movie had so many deeper issues than just action that I think the action parts took away from the movie imo, the purely fighting scenes I mean not the bloody gore stuff that was great.
also what Rorschach was planning on doing I don't think was totally right, and just because he didn't compromise doesn't mean he was right either, it just meant he was so arrogant he believed he was constantly right, like adrian veidt. it's so hard to tell who actually cares in the fucking story though you know?
they all become heros but none of them are really heroic.
night owl II is only powerful when he is in his suite or beating up people, thats the only time he can get a boner. not that heroic.
rorschach constantly says how much he hates the city, it seems the only reason he gets involved in a serious way is because he fears the killer is going to attempted an attack on his life next. not because he cares about people or is a hero.
silk specter II was just trying emulating her mother's foot steps.
john was just john, trying to figure out how things worked with a passing interest in human affairs.
so funny how because the comedian was gov. he was so "heroic" in the publics eye, the movie has so many layers of irony and satire all tied up in a nice little action hero movie.